{"atlasLayout":{"columns":12,"coordinateOrigin":"zero_based_top_left","geographicScale":false,"kind":"approximate_us_tile_grid","rows":8},"checkedAt":"2026-07-22","comparability":{"alignmentRequired":["source scope","decision status semantics","vintage","institutional reach","retention practice"],"caveat":"Source scope, decision semantics, vintage, institutional reach, and retention practice vary by state. This artifact supports disclosure provenance only; it does not establish comparable list sizes, overlap rates, or relative restrictiveness. Separately gated exact intersections are documented as identity evidence, never as a rank.","status":"not_established"},"kind":"state_publication_source_provenance","normalizationCohort":{"cohort":"P0","generatedAt":"2026-07-22T14:08:52Z","policy":"Michigan overlap is exact-only and never a rank. Only denied/restricted rows with a comparable ISBN-13 or exact normalized title-and-author pair are eligible.","states":[{"artifactCount":1,"artifacts":[{"adapter":{"id":"ca_html_v1","version":"1.0.0"},"artifactFilename":"disapproved-publications","artifactSha256":"46ee48a490c70ebbec67de57101e69f2792b0dcf42dcfbfec77fc69bcaec10b8","normalizedRows":4727,"parserGates":{"failedCount":0,"failedGateIds":[],"gateIds":["A0","A1","A2","A3","A4"],"passedCount":5},"parserStatus":"parsed","refusalReason":null,"sourceFormat":"HTML table","sourceUrl":"https://www.cdcr.ca.gov/family-resources/disapproved-publications/"}],"exactMichiganIntersection":{"caveat":"Overlap is not a rank. It counts exact identifiers or exact normalized title-and-author pairs among denied/restricted rows only; fuzzy and title-only matches are excluded. Different source scopes and vintages remain incomparable.","comparisonStatuses":["computed_exact_only"],"eligibleStateRows":2919,"matchedMichiganRows":2,"matchedStateRows":2,"methodCounts":{"exact_normalized_title_author":2}},"identityStatus":"exact_comparable","normalizedRows":4727,"parsedArtifactCount":1,"parserStatus":"accepted","postalCode":"CA","state":"California"},{"artifactCount":2,"artifacts":[{"adapter":{"id":"fl_historical_pdf_v1","version":"1.0.0"},"artifactFilename":"LRC_Decisions_1991-2011___A-Z___Revised_2015-09-09.pdf","artifactSha256":"36b82110d150fd53b3e57cf6140c1efc51030252f63f86b491b649dfb3826a6c","normalizedRows":12539,"parserGates":{"failedCount":0,"failedGateIds":[],"gateIds":["A0","A1","A2","A3","A4","A5","A6","A7","A8"],"passedCount":9},"parserStatus":"parsed","refusalReason":null,"sourceFormat":"PDF","sourceUrl":"https://cdn.muckrock.com/foia_files/2025/09/19/LRC_Decisions_1991-2011___A-Z___Revised_2015-09-09.pdf"},{"adapter":{"id":"fl_xlsx_v1","version":"1.0.0"},"artifactFilename":"LRC_DECISIONS_2012_-_PRESENT.xlsx","artifactSha256":"f62ee11763018d2dbcb43ef7d84ab11ef84e2bb6f4c614b64d66a7be236a7724","normalizedRows":25614,"parserGates":{"failedCount":0,"failedGateIds":[],"gateIds":["A0","A1","A2","A3","A4","A5","A6"],"passedCount":7},"parserStatus":"parsed","refusalReason":null,"sourceFormat":"XLSX","sourceUrl":"https://cdn.muckrock.com/foia_files/2025/09/19/LRC_DECISIONS_2012_-_PRESENT.xlsx"}],"exactMichiganIntersection":{"caveat":"Overlap is not a rank. It counts exact identifiers or exact normalized title-and-author pairs among denied/restricted rows only; fuzzy and title-only matches are excluded. Different source scopes and vintages remain incomparable.","comparisonStatuses":["computed_exact_only"],"eligibleStateRows":10796,"matchedMichiganRows":1,"matchedStateRows":1,"methodCounts":{"exact_normalized_title_author":1}},"identityStatus":"exact_comparable","normalizedRows":38153,"parsedArtifactCount":2,"parserStatus":"accepted","postalCode":"FL","state":"Florida"},{"artifactCount":1,"artifacts":[{"adapter":{"id":"ga_bullets_pdf_v1","version":"1.0.0"},"artifactFilename":"PRC_List_2025.pdf","artifactSha256":"a4d0240a36579dfae6692436cdd8a9e704acee814716c69ca998172e08b63441","normalizedRows":339,"parserGates":{"failedCount":0,"failedGateIds":[],"gateIds":["A0","A1","A2","A3","A4","A5"],"passedCount":6},"parserStatus":"parsed","refusalReason":null,"sourceFormat":"PDF","sourceUrl":"https://cdn.muckrock.com/foia_files/2025/09/09/PRC_List_2025.pdf"}],"exactMichiganIntersection":{"caveat":"Overlap is not a rank. It counts exact identifiers or exact normalized title-and-author pairs among denied/restricted rows only; fuzzy and title-only matches are excluded. Different source scopes and vintages remain incomparable.","comparisonStatuses":["not_computed_incomparable_identity"],"eligibleStateRows":0,"matchedMichiganRows":null,"matchedStateRows":null,"methodCounts":{}},"identityStatus":"incomparable_identity","normalizedRows":339,"parsedArtifactCount":1,"parserStatus":"accepted","postalCode":"GA","state":"Georgia"},{"artifactCount":2,"artifacts":[{"adapter":{"id":"il_fixed_columns_banned_v1","version":"1.0.0"},"artifactFilename":"Banned_Books_9.11.25.pdf","artifactSha256":"0b392c27b45d89633100e8ea5ca261aacb243fac1fdc9dab0a57a002b0ab79dd","normalizedRows":2,"parserGates":{"failedCount":0,"failedGateIds":[],"gateIds":["A0","A1","A2","A3","A4","A5"],"passedCount":6},"parserStatus":"parsed","refusalReason":null,"sourceFormat":"PDF","sourceUrl":"https://cdn.muckrock.com/foia_files/2025/09/15/Banned_Books_9.11.25.pdf"},{"adapter":{"id":"il_fixed_columns_disapproved_v1","version":"1.0.0"},"artifactFilename":"Disapproved_Books_9.11.25.pdf","artifactSha256":"f17cd1234ab5080a83375863fc4b30a0f10081636e6b285a7c0a443d344ee18f","normalizedRows":919,"parserGates":{"failedCount":0,"failedGateIds":[],"gateIds":["A0","A1","A2","A3","A4","A5"],"passedCount":6},"parserStatus":"parsed","refusalReason":null,"sourceFormat":"PDF","sourceUrl":"https://cdn.muckrock.com/foia_files/2025/09/15/Disapproved_Books_9.11.25.pdf"}],"exactMichiganIntersection":{"caveat":"Overlap is not a rank. It counts exact identifiers or exact normalized title-and-author pairs among denied/restricted rows only; fuzzy and title-only matches are excluded. Different source scopes and vintages remain incomparable.","comparisonStatuses":["computed_exact_only"],"eligibleStateRows":393,"matchedMichiganRows":10,"matchedStateRows":12,"methodCounts":{"exact_isbn13":12}},"identityStatus":"exact_comparable","normalizedRows":921,"parsedArtifactCount":2,"parserStatus":"accepted","postalCode":"IL","state":"Illinois"},{"artifactCount":1,"artifacts":[{"adapter":{"id":"mi_reviewed_pdf_v1","version":"1.0.0"},"artifactFilename":"Restricted-Publication-List_1-12-2026.pdf","artifactSha256":"a810776a4822d97766b468aae4cbd7e6acae19519fee537b9d07d2326542ac94","normalizedRows":312,"parserGates":{"failedCount":0,"failedGateIds":[],"gateIds":["A0","A1","A2","A3"],"passedCount":4},"parserStatus":"parsed","refusalReason":null,"sourceFormat":"PDF","sourceUrl":"https://www.michigan.gov/corrections/-/media/Project/Websites/corrections/Files/Public-Information/Restricted-Publication-List_1-12-2026.pdf?hash=B331889F6270846B473D00FD55D7ED09&rev=e9f9581906c4441885f14d4499280813"}],"exactMichiganIntersection":{"caveat":"Overlap is not a rank. It counts exact identifiers or exact normalized title-and-author pairs among denied/restricted rows only; fuzzy and title-only matches are excluded. Different source scopes and vintages remain incomparable.","comparisonStatuses":["not_computed_reference_state"],"eligibleStateRows":0,"matchedMichiganRows":null,"matchedStateRows":null,"methodCounts":{}},"identityStatus":"reference_state","normalizedRows":312,"parsedArtifactCount":1,"parserStatus":"accepted","postalCode":"MI","state":"Michigan"},{"artifactCount":1,"artifacts":[{"adapter":{"id":"nj_single_column_pdf_v1","version":"1.0.0"},"artifactFilename":"250616_NJDOC_UNAUTHORIZED_PUBLICATIONS.pdf","artifactSha256":"e38632056dbcb1a231203f2366ca0dcc707149ebf8aca5b236569cf00c37d454","normalizedRows":265,"parserGates":{"failedCount":0,"failedGateIds":[],"gateIds":["A0","A1","A2","A3","A4"],"passedCount":5},"parserStatus":"parsed","refusalReason":null,"sourceFormat":"PDF","sourceUrl":"https://www.nj.gov/corrections/pdf/OffenderPublications/250616_NJDOC_UNAUTHORIZED_PUBLICATIONS.pdf"}],"exactMichiganIntersection":{"caveat":"Overlap is not a rank. It counts exact identifiers or exact normalized title-and-author pairs among denied/restricted rows only; fuzzy and title-only matches are excluded. Different source scopes and vintages remain incomparable.","comparisonStatuses":["not_computed_incomparable_identity"],"eligibleStateRows":0,"matchedMichiganRows":null,"matchedStateRows":null,"methodCounts":{}},"identityStatus":"incomparable_identity","normalizedRows":265,"parsedArtifactCount":1,"parserStatus":"accepted","postalCode":"NJ","state":"New Jersey"},{"artifactCount":1,"artifacts":[{"adapter":{"id":"tx_spreadsheetml_v1","version":"1.0.0"},"artifactFilename":"DENIED_BOOKS_20250702.xml","artifactSha256":"cd5a9713a82741b095fa3e3fcd7cbc25294b305ed5207afacbdfa8bebb7c78d2","normalizedRows":10663,"parserGates":{"failedCount":0,"failedGateIds":[],"gateIds":["A0","A1","A2","A3","A4"],"passedCount":5},"parserStatus":"parsed","refusalReason":null,"sourceFormat":"XML","sourceUrl":"https://cdn.muckrock.com/foia_files/2025/09/12/DENIED_BOOKS_20250702.xml"}],"exactMichiganIntersection":{"caveat":"Overlap is not a rank. It counts exact identifiers or exact normalized title-and-author pairs among denied/restricted rows only; fuzzy and title-only matches are excluded. Different source scopes and vintages remain incomparable.","comparisonStatuses":["computed_exact_only"],"eligibleStateRows":10659,"matchedMichiganRows":18,"matchedStateRows":21,"methodCounts":{"exact_normalized_title_author":21}},"identityStatus":"exact_comparable","normalizedRows":10663,"parsedArtifactCount":1,"parserStatus":"accepted","postalCode":"TX","state":"Texas"},{"artifactCount":1,"artifacts":[{"adapter":{"id":"wa_refused_complex_pdf_v1","version":"1.0.0"},"artifactFilename":"400-RE003.pdf","artifactSha256":"f71e3ebd3ccf210e8a576a4116915af15072af22d2e82036a32b8d9be46d3991","normalizedRows":0,"parserGates":{"failedCount":2,"failedGateIds":["A1","A2"],"gateIds":["A0","A1","A2"],"passedCount":1},"parserStatus":"refused","refusalReason":"The 109-page Excel-generated PDF interleaves multi-line cells from review, committee-decision, and appeal columns. The visible rows also include pending records. No lossless column boundary or final-outcome rule is proven for this exact artifact, so normalization is refused.","sourceFormat":"PDF","sourceUrl":"https://doc.wa.gov/sites/default/files/2026-02/400-RE003.pdf"}],"exactMichiganIntersection":{"caveat":"Overlap is not a rank. It counts exact identifiers or exact normalized title-and-author pairs among denied/restricted rows only; fuzzy and title-only matches are excluded. Different source scopes and vintages remain incomparable.","comparisonStatuses":["not_computed_refused"],"eligibleStateRows":0,"matchedMichiganRows":null,"matchedStateRows":null,"methodCounts":{}},"identityStatus":"parser_refused","normalizedRows":0,"parsedArtifactCount":0,"parserStatus":"refused","postalCode":"WA","state":"Washington"}],"status":"locked","summary":{"attemptedArtifactCount":10,"attemptedStateCount":8,"exactIdentityEligibleStateRows":24767,"exactIdentityStateCount":4,"normalizedEntryCount":55380,"parsedArtifactCount":9,"parsedStateCount":7,"refusedArtifactCount":1,"statesWithExactMichiganIntersection":4}},"p1NormalizationCohort":{"artifacts":[{"adapterGates":{"failedCount":0,"gateCount":6,"passedCount":6},"artifactSha256":"0a436bcbd099bcb95da1e002a887c368d1ccdb1ad9f03b26bdf0318c9effddb1","decisionStatusCounts":{"historical_restricted":4632},"eligibility":{"identityRows":2305,"reviewedDecisionRows":4632},"exactMichiganIntersection":{"comparisonStatus":"computed_exact_identity","matchedMichiganRows":19,"matchedStateRows":19,"methodCounts":{"exact_isbn13":19}},"normalizedSourceRows":4632,"parserStatus":"parsed","postalCode":"AZ","sourceUrl":"https://s3.amazonaws.com/tmp-gfx-public-data/banned-books20220819/banned_book_data_az-list.csv","state":"Arizona"},{"adapterGates":{"failedCount":0,"gateCount":7,"passedCount":7},"artifactSha256":"3db728818738d3dfe809f0d4a30ad24ce81b47bf612f0de75fdf42aa7764ad94","decisionStatusCounts":{"denied":125,"partially_restricted":59},"eligibility":{"identityRows":0,"reviewedDecisionRows":184},"exactMichiganIntersection":{"comparisonStatus":"not_computed_identity_unavailable","matchedMichiganRows":null,"matchedStateRows":null,"methodCounts":null},"normalizedSourceRows":184,"parserStatus":"parsed","postalCode":"CO","sourceUrl":"https://www.prisonlegalnews.org/media/publications/Colorado_-_CENSORED_PUBLICATIONS_10-2018_to_9-2019.pdf","state":"Colorado"},{"adapterGates":{"failedCount":0,"gateCount":5,"passedCount":5},"artifactSha256":"10e5202e0627364d6c9bb322aac29a169f341b0081759fe92806262fb6279ce5","decisionStatusCounts":{"denied":520},"eligibility":{"identityRows":473,"reviewedDecisionRows":520},"exactMichiganIntersection":{"comparisonStatus":"computed_exact_identity","matchedMichiganRows":0,"matchedStateRows":0,"methodCounts":{}},"normalizedSourceRows":520,"parserStatus":"parsed","postalCode":"CT","sourceUrl":"https://www.bookstoprisoners.net/_files/ugd/ea950d_4d4c99c6006c45feae553c46dff8e0a2.xlsx?dn=Connecticut%20to%202023.xlsx","state":"Connecticut"},{"adapterGates":{"failedCount":0,"gateCount":5,"passedCount":5},"artifactSha256":"1f6c74dea7b398d0899203f85de0170b2c36b08502fa184cf2d20392b75b6d3d","decisionStatusCounts":{"historical_restricted":431},"eligibility":{"identityRows":158,"reviewedDecisionRows":431},"exactMichiganIntersection":{"comparisonStatus":"computed_exact_identity","matchedMichiganRows":2,"matchedStateRows":2,"methodCounts":{"exact_normalized_title_author":2}},"normalizedSourceRows":431,"parserStatus":"parsed","postalCode":"IA","sourceUrl":"https://s3.amazonaws.com/tmp-gfx-public-data/banned-books20220819/banned_book_data_ia-list.csv","state":"Iowa"},{"adapterGates":{"failedCount":0,"gateCount":5,"passedCount":5},"artifactSha256":"fd19cf031fe64d83d1e4caa802f3a488bc7ea9f2d091f047a30284612e153d49","decisionStatusCounts":{"historical_restricted":99},"eligibility":{"identityRows":79,"reviewedDecisionRows":99},"exactMichiganIntersection":{"comparisonStatus":"computed_exact_identity","matchedMichiganRows":0,"matchedStateRows":0,"methodCounts":{}},"normalizedSourceRows":99,"parserStatus":"parsed","postalCode":"KS","sourceUrl":"https://s3.amazonaws.com/tmp-gfx-public-data/banned-books20220819/banned_book_data_ks-list.csv","state":"Kansas"},{"adapterGates":{"failedCount":0,"gateCount":4,"passedCount":4},"artifactSha256":"696ad502b48cbb38b4bc424b7ae8551a9a66e3e04e029d4f473d96c68e927b0b","decisionStatusCounts":{"denied":235},"eligibility":{"identityRows":235,"reviewedDecisionRows":235},"exactMichiganIntersection":{"comparisonStatus":"computed_exact_identity","matchedMichiganRows":1,"matchedStateRows":1,"methodCounts":{"exact_normalized_title_author":1}},"normalizedSourceRows":235,"parserStatus":"parsed","postalCode":"MT","sourceUrl":"https://www.bookstoprisoners.net/_files/ugd/ea950d_c65bca0fb5ab44b18b424e49cabe6774.xlsx?dn=Montana%20List.xlsx","state":"Montana"},{"adapterGates":{"failedCount":0,"gateCount":5,"passedCount":5},"artifactSha256":"e53722820625a314ca6125a018576adee469d393277ccb0d918039a3a13a01c4","decisionStatusCounts":{"historical_restricted":600},"eligibility":{"identityRows":0,"reviewedDecisionRows":0},"exactMichiganIntersection":{"comparisonStatus":"not_computed_unpublished_source_status","matchedMichiganRows":null,"matchedStateRows":null,"methodCounts":null},"normalizedSourceRows":600,"parserStatus":"parsed","postalCode":"NC","sourceUrl":"https://s3.amazonaws.com/tmp-gfx-public-data/banned-books20220819/banned_book_data_nc-list.csv","state":"North Carolina"},{"adapterGates":{"failedCount":1,"gateCount":2,"passedCount":1},"artifactSha256":"a5ec4a06b951ab85f2204b7c7984a18e1b0c2d9454c8572ecb6076b9e9fe47c4","decisionStatusCounts":{},"eligibility":{"identityRows":0,"reviewedDecisionRows":0},"exactMichiganIntersection":{"comparisonStatus":"not_computed_refused","matchedMichiganRows":null,"matchedStateRows":null,"methodCounts":null},"normalizedSourceRows":0,"parserStatus":"refused","postalCode":"OR","sourceUrl":"https://www.bookstoprisoners.net/_files/ugd/ea950d_7d07959ba7de4e0e978d95f154aa688b.xls?dn=Oregon%20Rejected%202023.xls","state":"Oregon"},{"adapterGates":{"failedCount":0,"gateCount":5,"passedCount":5},"artifactSha256":"3edcc8eeca910db956da0a1e1fd3622f86206a96c450f5f4578ee7bced415050","decisionStatusCounts":{"approved":33,"denied":38,"unknown":5},"eligibility":{"identityRows":0,"reviewedDecisionRows":38},"exactMichiganIntersection":{"comparisonStatus":"not_computed_identity_unavailable","matchedMichiganRows":null,"matchedStateRows":null,"methodCounts":null},"normalizedSourceRows":76,"parserStatus":"parsed","postalCode":"RI","sourceUrl":"https://www.bookstoprisoners.net/_files/ugd/ea950d_c7145bd90cd34b00843572f886113b03.xlsx?dn=Rhode%20Island.xlsx","state":"Rhode Island"},{"adapterGates":{"failedCount":0,"gateCount":6,"passedCount":6},"artifactSha256":"adf4c135e3c9afb2bcf2f55c64c42a2ce583c875eb654d2ef877ed8681cdb0c6","decisionStatusCounts":{"approved":14,"denied":1479,"unknown":6},"eligibility":{"identityRows":0,"reviewedDecisionRows":1479},"exactMichiganIntersection":{"comparisonStatus":"not_computed_identity_unavailable","matchedMichiganRows":null,"matchedStateRows":null,"methodCounts":null},"normalizedSourceRows":1499,"parserStatus":"parsed","postalCode":"SC","sourceUrl":"https://s3.amazonaws.com/tmp-gfx-public-data/banned-books20220819/banned_book_data_sc-list.csv","state":"South Carolina"},{"adapterGates":{"failedCount":0,"gateCount":5,"passedCount":5},"artifactSha256":"b8d51deae32621f5904701d7265d9a5dd2ef7017f22912f4cc98ceeaba556720","decisionStatusCounts":{"denied":7198},"eligibility":{"identityRows":2527,"reviewedDecisionRows":7198},"exactMichiganIntersection":{"comparisonStatus":"computed_exact_identity","matchedMichiganRows":2,"matchedStateRows":2,"methodCounts":{"exact_normalized_title_author":2}},"normalizedSourceRows":7198,"parserStatus":"parsed","postalCode":"VA","sourceUrl":"https://www.bookstoprisoners.net/_files/ugd/ea950d_e5b62f01b9e34f43bc1b2788e6ee9126.xlsx?dn=Virginia%20to%202022.xlsx","state":"Virginia"},{"adapterGates":{"failedCount":0,"gateCount":6,"passedCount":6},"artifactSha256":"c2748e2f4eed77c1759389c17f984a5921e121637e326dce58928aaa0db6f0a3","decisionStatusCounts":{"approved":81,"unknown":1},"eligibility":{"identityRows":0,"reviewedDecisionRows":0},"exactMichiganIntersection":{"comparisonStatus":"not_computed_no_reviewed_denial_rows","matchedMichiganRows":null,"matchedStateRows":null,"methodCounts":null},"normalizedSourceRows":82,"parserStatus":"parsed","postalCode":"WI","sourceUrl":"https://s3.amazonaws.com/tmp-gfx-public-data/banned-books20220819/banned_book_data_wi-list-1.csv","state":"Wisconsin"},{"adapterGates":{"failedCount":0,"gateCount":6,"passedCount":6},"artifactSha256":"388d000971045c36f4dded8c5d5ca16d52d532fe55140d58739a82846a3375f0","decisionStatusCounts":{"denied":2175,"unknown":24},"eligibility":{"identityRows":2106,"reviewedDecisionRows":2175},"exactMichiganIntersection":{"comparisonStatus":"computed_exact_identity","matchedMichiganRows":5,"matchedStateRows":5,"methodCounts":{"exact_normalized_title_author":5}},"normalizedSourceRows":2199,"parserStatus":"parsed","postalCode":"WI","sourceUrl":"https://s3.amazonaws.com/tmp-gfx-public-data/banned-books20220819/banned_book_data_wi-list-2.csv","state":"Wisconsin"}],"caveat":"These are exact identity intersections between historical, differently scoped source artifacts and Michigan's pinned 2026 reference. They are not a contemporaneous statewide-ban overlap, list-size comparison, rate, rank, or measure of relative restrictiveness. Counts use source-artifact rows, not unique publications.","cohort":"P1","countingUnit":"source_artifact_rows","generatedAt":"2026-07-22T15:52:09Z","michiganReference":{"artifactSha256":"a810776a4822d97766b468aae4cbd7e6acae19519fee537b9d07d2326542ac94","binding":"exact_sha256_edition_row_count","edition":"2026-01-12"},"policy":"Only exact ISBN-13 or nonblank exact normalized title-and-author identity is considered. Decision eligibility is pinned by artifact SHA-256 and reviewed raw source semantics.","snapshotPolicy":"Every artifact remains a separate source snapshot. Wisconsin's two records must not be deduplicated or summed as unique publications.","status":"reviewed","summary":{"artifactsWithExactMichiganIntersection":5,"attemptedArtifactCount":13,"attemptedStateCount":12,"computedExactIntersectionArtifactCount":7,"decisionStatusCounts":{"approved":128,"denied":11770,"historical_restricted":5762,"partially_restricted":59,"unknown":36},"distinctMatchedMichiganRows":25,"identityEligibleRows":7883,"matchedStateRows":29,"methodCounts":{"exact_isbn13":19,"exact_normalized_title_author":10},"normalizedSourceRows":17755,"parsedArtifactCount":12,"refusedArtifactCount":1,"reviewedDecisionEligibleRows":16991}},"p2NormalizationCohort":{"artifacts":[{"acquisitionStatus":"custody_verified_quarantined","artifactId":"p2-id-7e552cec4af5","artifactSha256":"7e552cec4af529255705efb0bf03dba5e2400f832efefcbb94f73766779c2025","postalCode":"ID","sourceFormat":"PDF","sourceScopes":[{"artifactId":"p2-id-7e552cec4af5","decisionStatusCounts":null,"eligibility":null,"exactMichiganIntersection":{"comparisonStatus":"not_computed_privacy_refused","matchedMichiganRows":null,"matchedStateRows":null,"methodCounts":null},"id":"p2-id-s01","label":"Whole reviewed artifact","normalizedSourceRows":null}],"sourceUrl":"https://www.bookstoprisoners.net/_files/ugd/ea950d_24312dbbbf024b3488be3daa23c94654.pdf","stages":[{"id":"custody","status":"cleared"},{"id":"privacy","status":"stopped"},{"id":"parser","status":"not-reached"},{"id":"decision","status":"not-reached"},{"id":"identity","status":"not-reached"},{"id":"intersection","status":"not-reached"}],"state":"Idaho","vintage":"2021/2022 PDF only"},{"acquisitionStatus":"acquired_validated","artifactId":"p2-la-c848a83616dd","artifactSha256":"c848a83616ddc5441a1db5d81bd64ca1144d2ce5a3fca2198b33d1c02e6b373b","postalCode":"LA","sourceFormat":"DOCX","sourceScopes":[{"artifactId":"p2-la-c848a83616dd","decisionStatusCounts":{"approved":0,"denied":3164,"unknown":0},"eligibility":{"identityRows":1546,"reviewedDecisionRows":3164},"exactMichiganIntersection":{"comparisonStatus":"computed_exact_identity","matchedMichiganRows":5,"matchedStateRows":5,"methodCounts":{"exact_normalized_title_author":5}},"id":"p2-la-s01","label":"Whole reviewed artifact","normalizedSourceRows":3164}],"sourceUrl":"https://www.bookstoprisoners.net/_files/ugd/ea950d_85789755e05e488c8920f5ae8ffa2bef.docx?dn=Louisiana%20to%202023.docx","stages":[{"id":"custody","status":"cleared"},{"id":"privacy","status":"cleared"},{"id":"parser","status":"cleared"},{"id":"decision","status":"cleared"},{"id":"identity","status":"cleared"},{"id":"intersection","status":"cleared"}],"state":"Louisiana","vintage":"Through February 2023"},{"acquisitionStatus":"acquired_validated","artifactId":"p2-ne-91dd2230e6ac","artifactSha256":"91dd2230e6acddff8cc5ef249aa587393c3d13f12acd1d3427572fc13ad8fb6a","postalCode":"NE","sourceFormat":"XLS","sourceScopes":[{"artifactId":"p2-ne-91dd2230e6ac","decisionStatusCounts":{"approved":0,"denied":0,"unknown":58},"eligibility":{"identityRows":0,"reviewedDecisionRows":0},"exactMichiganIntersection":{"comparisonStatus":"not_computed_no_reviewed_denial_rows","matchedMichiganRows":null,"matchedStateRows":null,"methodCounts":null},"id":"p2-ne-s01","label":"2011","normalizedSourceRows":58},{"artifactId":"p2-ne-91dd2230e6ac","decisionStatusCounts":{"approved":0,"denied":0,"unknown":20},"eligibility":{"identityRows":0,"reviewedDecisionRows":0},"exactMichiganIntersection":{"comparisonStatus":"not_computed_no_reviewed_denial_rows","matchedMichiganRows":null,"matchedStateRows":null,"methodCounts":null},"id":"p2-ne-s02","label":"2012","normalizedSourceRows":20},{"artifactId":"p2-ne-91dd2230e6ac","decisionStatusCounts":{"approved":0,"denied":0,"unknown":17},"eligibility":{"identityRows":0,"reviewedDecisionRows":0},"exactMichiganIntersection":{"comparisonStatus":"not_computed_no_reviewed_denial_rows","matchedMichiganRows":null,"matchedStateRows":null,"methodCounts":null},"id":"p2-ne-s03","label":"2013","normalizedSourceRows":17},{"artifactId":"p2-ne-91dd2230e6ac","decisionStatusCounts":{"approved":0,"denied":0,"unknown":24},"eligibility":{"identityRows":0,"reviewedDecisionRows":0},"exactMichiganIntersection":{"comparisonStatus":"not_computed_no_reviewed_denial_rows","matchedMichiganRows":null,"matchedStateRows":null,"methodCounts":null},"id":"p2-ne-s04","label":"2014","normalizedSourceRows":24},{"artifactId":"p2-ne-91dd2230e6ac","decisionStatusCounts":{"approved":5,"denied":1,"unknown":21},"eligibility":{"identityRows":0,"reviewedDecisionRows":1},"exactMichiganIntersection":{"comparisonStatus":"not_computed_identity_unavailable","matchedMichiganRows":null,"matchedStateRows":null,"methodCounts":null},"id":"p2-ne-s05","label":"2015","normalizedSourceRows":27},{"artifactId":"p2-ne-91dd2230e6ac","decisionStatusCounts":{"approved":25,"denied":15,"unknown":1},"eligibility":{"identityRows":0,"reviewedDecisionRows":15},"exactMichiganIntersection":{"comparisonStatus":"not_computed_identity_unavailable","matchedMichiganRows":null,"matchedStateRows":null,"methodCounts":null},"id":"p2-ne-s06","label":"2017-Books etc.","normalizedSourceRows":41},{"artifactId":"p2-ne-91dd2230e6ac","decisionStatusCounts":{"approved":31,"denied":1,"unknown":30},"eligibility":{"identityRows":0,"reviewedDecisionRows":1},"exactMichiganIntersection":{"comparisonStatus":"not_computed_identity_unavailable","matchedMichiganRows":null,"matchedStateRows":null,"methodCounts":null},"id":"p2-ne-s07","label":"Hustler","normalizedSourceRows":62},{"artifactId":"p2-ne-91dd2230e6ac","decisionStatusCounts":{"approved":53,"denied":30,"unknown":8},"eligibility":{"identityRows":0,"reviewedDecisionRows":30},"exactMichiganIntersection":{"comparisonStatus":"not_computed_identity_unavailable","matchedMichiganRows":null,"matchedStateRows":null,"methodCounts":null},"id":"p2-ne-s08","label":"BUTTMAN","normalizedSourceRows":91},{"artifactId":"p2-ne-91dd2230e6ac","decisionStatusCounts":{"approved":175,"denied":64,"unknown":15},"eligibility":{"identityRows":0,"reviewedDecisionRows":64},"exactMichiganIntersection":{"comparisonStatus":"not_computed_identity_unavailable","matchedMichiganRows":null,"matchedStateRows":null,"methodCounts":null},"id":"p2-ne-s09","label":"Tattoo Books","normalizedSourceRows":254},{"artifactId":"p2-ne-91dd2230e6ac","decisionStatusCounts":{"approved":313,"denied":276,"unknown":13},"eligibility":{"identityRows":0,"reviewedDecisionRows":276},"exactMichiganIntersection":{"comparisonStatus":"not_computed_identity_unavailable","matchedMichiganRows":null,"matchedStateRows":null,"methodCounts":null},"id":"p2-ne-s10","label":"Mags&Books","normalizedSourceRows":602}],"sourceUrl":"https://www.bookstoprisoners.net/_files/ugd/ea950d_a5c24e5439ed4dac97d708cc54c207f0.xls?dn=Nebraska%20TCSI%20.xls","stages":[{"id":"custody","status":"cleared"},{"id":"privacy","status":"cleared"},{"id":"parser","status":"cleared"},{"id":"decision","status":"cleared"},{"id":"identity","status":"stopped"},{"id":"intersection","status":"not-reached"}],"state":"Nebraska","vintage":"Entries described as 2011-2021"},{"acquisitionStatus":"acquired_validated","artifactId":"p2-nh-13df5d11f922","artifactSha256":"13df5d11f9227ddc47d5cec2890f89dbfd14adf4598d9f1109e69dff9cb55646","postalCode":"NH","sourceFormat":"PDF","sourceScopes":[{"artifactId":"p2-nh-13df5d11f922","decisionStatusCounts":{"approved":0,"denied":130,"unknown":0},"eligibility":{"identityRows":130,"reviewedDecisionRows":130},"exactMichiganIntersection":{"comparisonStatus":"computed_exact_identity","matchedMichiganRows":0,"matchedStateRows":0,"methodCounts":{}},"id":"p2-nh-s01","label":"Whole reviewed artifact","normalizedSourceRows":130}],"sourceUrl":"https://www.bookstoprisoners.net/_files/ugd/ea950d_47ef9598d9f54f8092789851ddf78359.pdf","stages":[{"id":"custody","status":"cleared"},{"id":"privacy","status":"cleared"},{"id":"parser","status":"cleared"},{"id":"decision","status":"cleared"},{"id":"identity","status":"cleared"},{"id":"intersection","status":"cleared"}],"state":"New Hampshire","vintage":"May/June 2019"},{"acquisitionStatus":"acquired_validated","artifactId":"p2-oh-475569964a68","artifactSha256":"475569964a6881b5e36503291f6062d6155bdb12e84e1d228057d65505ec4f92","postalCode":"OH","sourceFormat":"PDF","sourceScopes":[{"artifactId":"p2-oh-475569964a68","decisionStatusCounts":{"approved":218,"denied":293,"unknown":0},"eligibility":{"identityRows":292,"reviewedDecisionRows":293},"exactMichiganIntersection":{"comparisonStatus":"computed_exact_identity","matchedMichiganRows":1,"matchedStateRows":1,"methodCounts":{"exact_normalized_title_author":1}},"id":"p2-oh-s01","label":"Whole reviewed artifact","normalizedSourceRows":511}],"sourceUrl":"https://www.bookstoprisoners.net/_files/ugd/ea950d_e12084fcc10a4dea820e8da43e767936.pdf","stages":[{"id":"custody","status":"cleared"},{"id":"privacy","status":"cleared"},{"id":"parser","status":"cleared"},{"id":"decision","status":"cleared"},{"id":"identity","status":"cleared"},{"id":"intersection","status":"cleared"}],"state":"Ohio","vintage":"January 2022"},{"acquisitionStatus":"acquired_validated","artifactId":"p2-wy-12a1ff6f9930","artifactSha256":"12a1ff6f99302f9dc11b8394834169450cb14db83cf16ad7fcaaddce2e827e45","postalCode":"WY","sourceFormat":"DOCX","sourceScopes":[{"artifactId":"p2-wy-12a1ff6f9930","decisionStatusCounts":{"approved":0,"denied":89,"unknown":0},"eligibility":{"identityRows":0,"reviewedDecisionRows":89},"exactMichiganIntersection":{"comparisonStatus":"not_computed_identity_unavailable","matchedMichiganRows":null,"matchedStateRows":null,"methodCounts":null},"id":"p2-wy-s01","label":"Whole reviewed artifact","normalizedSourceRows":89}],"sourceUrl":"https://www.bookstoprisoners.net/_files/ugd/ea950d_78702e7fc3ea4be6b4a0e73e2cad0561.docx?dn=Wyoming%20publications-%202022.docx","stages":[{"id":"custody","status":"cleared"},{"id":"privacy","status":"cleared"},{"id":"parser","status":"cleared"},{"id":"decision","status":"cleared"},{"id":"identity","status":"stopped"},{"id":"intersection","status":"not-reached"}],"state":"Wyoming","vintage":"Through 2022-10-26"}],"caveat":"Counts are source-scope rows from differently scoped and dated records; they do not establish a comparative score or unique-publication total.","cohort":"P2","countingUnit":"source_scope_rows","generatedAt":"2026-07-22T18:59:22.026Z","michiganReference":{"artifactSha256":"a810776a4822d97766b468aae4cbd7e6acae19519fee537b9d07d2326542ac94","binding":"exact_sha256_edition_row_count","edition":"2026-01-12"},"policy":"Only exact ISBN-13 or nonblank exact normalized title-and-author identity may produce an intersection; title-only and fuzzy matching are excluded.","snapshotPolicy":"All six artifacts remain separate, and Nebraska's ten ordered worksheet scopes remain ten branches without cross-sheet deduplication.","status":"reviewed","summary":{"artifactsWithExactMichiganIntersection":2,"attemptedArtifactCount":6,"attemptedStateCount":6,"computedExactIntersectionArtifactCount":3,"custodyVerifiedArtifactCount":6,"decisionStatusCounts":{"approved":820,"denied":4063,"unknown":207},"distinctMatchedMichiganRows":5,"identityEligibleRows":1968,"matchedStateRows":6,"methodCounts":{"exact_normalized_title_author":6},"normalizedSourceRows":5090,"parsedArtifactCount":5,"privacyClearedArtifactCount":5,"privacyRefusedArtifactCount":1,"reviewedDecisionEligibleRows":4063}},"schemaVersion":"2.2.0","scope":"Public provenance for 29 state prison publication-review sources. The source ledger was prepared through metadata-only research; acquisition fields combine a byte-verified P0 parser-input cohort covering eight states and ten artifacts with a byte-verified P1 custody-only cohort covering twelve states and thirteen artifacts and a byte-verified P2 custody cohort covering six states and six artifacts. P0, P1, and P2 parser and exact-identity gates are published without local paths or row-level matches. P1 evidence stays separated by source artifact; P2 evidence additionally preserves fifteen source scopes. These cohorts do not establish contemporaneous statewide-ban overlap, rates, ranks, or relative restrictiveness.","sources":{"acquisitionManifests":{"P0":{"generatedAt":"2026-07-22T14:08:52Z","schemaVersion":"1.0.0","sha256":"40099c1ab3237f68ae1b79f3e23fb03a7cb83b4959ce3a52d8527e4d977e4a93"},"P1":{"generatedAt":"2026-07-22T15:52:09Z","schemaVersion":"1.0.0","sha256":"35475353306f69f0ae0d09b445254bba681285e18b2e1d65e7323ec97a387792"},"P2":{"generatedAt":"2026-07-22T18:59:22.026Z","schemaVersion":"1.0.0","sha256":"dac58e04f079a201e1cbb2ab8ea009689038a9dbd40bbce2c941b38ac962380d"}},"ledger":{"schemaVersion":"1.0.0","sha256":"66bdc2d83d0af18e5d46a5914a212ba1deedc6b20152cd9a72caf082f32295e8"},"normalizationReport":{"generatedAt":"2026-07-22T14:08:52Z","schemaVersion":"1.0.0","sha256":"bdbac95d2b68a4392b882c9dbb047a55950540a143947767d4b6124b9be2ed6a"},"p1NormalizationReport":{"generatedAt":"2026-07-22T15:52:09Z","schemaVersion":"1.0.0","sha256":"170d06c9ad9fc539320c867baf6660a1de2d3e8b1361d7eb07b2d2cc4a19fa19"},"p2NebraskaFidelity":{"schemaVersion":"1.0.0","sha256":"2ce877c2450c31717dc764a470e1201e18b319540adfee35f87980c00da0d8fc"},"p2PreAcquisitionValidationReport":{"schemaVersion":"1.0.0","sha256":"039e5ebfd90e89f830c9f5b10e780f2329d88f96e0eab507be038ef6de59564d"},"p2PrivacyReview":{"sha256":"8f3815e53e058233e6101ce1dba797771ac1d0552efdf8d126ebd0c63b1a017f"},"p2PrivateIngestReport":{"generatedAt":"2026-07-22T18:59:22.026Z","schemaVersion":"1.0.0","sha256":"ee1fd4cac841793af4f39843bc7f8b825925306c43317a69c2ca451634f7bdf3"},"p2ValidationReport":{"schemaVersion":"1.1.0","sha256":"39ac15750347fcf495c66ee3a7cd92652d111395372a309368e7f5da7629e457"}},"states":[{"acquisition":{"artifactBytes":461361,"artifactCount":1,"artifactFormats":["CSV"],"custodyCohort":"P1","integrity":"verified","p0ParserCohort":false,"retrievedAt":["2026-07-22T15:51:38Z"],"status":"acquired"},"atlasGrid":{"column":0,"row":5},"comparability":{"caveat":"PEN reports that Arizona has no centralized list; the extract may represent reviewed or rejected items rather than a complete statewide list. Until those conditions are aligned with another source, cross-state list-size, overlap, and restrictiveness comparisons are not established.","status":"not_established"},"postalCode":"AZ","source":{"formats":["CSV"],"primary":{"format":"CSV","role":"data","url":"https://s3.amazonaws.com/tmp-gfx-public-data/banned-books20220819/banned_book_data_az-list.csv"},"priority":"P1","scope":"Historical normalized review or rejection records; not verified as a current centralized statewide ban list.","status":"ready","tier":"V2","vintage":"As of 2022-02-11"},"state":"Arizona"},{"acquisition":{"artifactBytes":976338,"artifactCount":1,"artifactFormats":["HTML table"],"custodyCohort":"P0","integrity":"verified","p0ParserCohort":true,"retrievedAt":["2026-07-22T14:07:22Z"],"status":"acquired"},"atlasGrid":{"column":0,"row":4},"comparability":{"caveat":"The HTML table is mutable and has no explicit edition date; a retrieval snapshot is required for reproducibility. Until those conditions are aligned with another source, cross-state list-size, overlap, and restrictiveness comparisons are not established.","status":"not_established"},"postalCode":"CA","source":{"formats":["HTML table"],"primary":{"format":"HTML table","role":"data","url":"https://www.cdcr.ca.gov/family-resources/disapproved-publications/"},"priority":"P0","scope":"Live statewide CDCR table of disapproved publications.","status":"ready","tier":"V3","vintage":"Live page checked 2026-07-22; entries include 2026 publication issues"},"state":"California"},{"acquisition":{"artifactBytes":184411,"artifactCount":1,"artifactFormats":["PDF"],"custodyCohort":"P1","integrity":"verified","p0ParserCohort":false,"retrievedAt":["2026-07-22T15:51:48Z"],"status":"acquired"},"atlasGrid":{"column":2,"row":4},"comparability":{"caveat":"Historical one-year window only; it is not evidence of Colorado's current list or complete historical practice. Until those conditions are aligned with another source, cross-state list-size, overlap, and restrictiveness comparisons are not established.","status":"not_established"},"postalCode":"CO","source":{"formats":["PDF"],"primary":{"format":"PDF","role":"data","url":"https://www.prisonlegalnews.org/media/publications/Colorado_-_CENSORED_PUBLICATIONS_10-2018_to_9-2019.pdf"},"priority":"P1","scope":"Historical list of fully censored publications released by Colorado DOC.","status":"ready","tier":"V3","vintage":"2018-10-15 through 2019-09"},"state":"Colorado"},{"acquisition":{"artifactBytes":73280,"artifactCount":1,"artifactFormats":["XLSX"],"custodyCohort":"P1","integrity":"verified","p0ParserCohort":false,"retrievedAt":["2026-07-22T15:51:50Z"],"status":"acquired"},"atlasGrid":{"column":10,"row":3},"comparability":{"caveat":"No source-specific purge rule was verified; vintages differ and must remain separate snapshots. Until those conditions are aligned with another source, cross-state list-size, overlap, and restrictiveness comparisons are not established.","status":"not_established"},"postalCode":"CT","source":{"formats":["XLSX","CSV"],"primary":{"format":"XLSX","role":"data","url":"https://www.bookstoprisoners.net/_files/ugd/ea950d_4d4c99c6006c45feae553c46dff8e0a2.xlsx?dn=Connecticut%20to%202023.xlsx"},"priority":"P1","scope":"State disapproved-publication records, with a newer raw mirror and an older normalized TMP extract.","status":"ready","tier":"V2","vintage":"Raw mirror through February 2023; TMP extract as of 2021-12-07"},"state":"Connecticut"},{"acquisition":{"artifactBytes":2653584,"artifactCount":2,"artifactFormats":["PDF","XLSX"],"custodyCohort":"P0","integrity":"verified","p0ParserCohort":true,"retrievedAt":["2026-07-22T14:08:09Z","2026-07-22T14:08:12Z"],"status":"acquired"},"atlasGrid":{"column":8,"row":7},"comparability":{"caveat":"Two source generations and possible revisions require snapshot-specific provenance; 'present' means the agency response date, not live synchronization. Until those conditions are aligned with another source, cross-state list-size, overlap, and restrictiveness comparisons are not established.","status":"not_established"},"postalCode":"FL","source":{"formats":["XLSX","PDF"],"primary":{"format":"XLSX","role":"data","url":"https://cdn.muckrock.com/foia_files/2025/09/19/LRC_DECISIONS_2012_-_PRESENT.xlsx"},"priority":"P0","scope":"Literature Review Committee decisions, split into a recent workbook and a historical PDF.","status":"ready","tier":"V2","vintage":"Historical PDF covers 1991-2011; workbook covers 2012-present as supplied 2025-09-19"},"state":"Florida"},{"acquisition":{"artifactBytes":185631,"artifactCount":1,"artifactFormats":["PDF"],"custodyCohort":"P0","integrity":"verified","p0ParserCohort":true,"retrievedAt":["2026-07-22T14:08:09Z"],"status":"acquired"},"atlasGrid":{"column":7,"row":6},"comparability":{"caveat":"Coverage start and agency retention policy are unverified; the file is a dated FOIA snapshot. Until those conditions are aligned with another source, cross-state list-size, overlap, and restrictiveness comparisons are not established.","status":"not_established"},"postalCode":"GA","source":{"formats":["PDF"],"primary":{"format":"PDF","role":"data","url":"https://cdn.muckrock.com/foia_files/2025/09/09/PRC_List_2025.pdf"},"priority":"P0","scope":"Publication Review Committee list released by Georgia DOC.","status":"ready","tier":"V2","vintage":"PRC List 2025, supplied 2025-09-09"},"state":"Georgia"},{"acquisition":{"artifactBytes":30192,"artifactCount":1,"artifactFormats":["CSV"],"custodyCohort":"P1","integrity":"verified","p0ParserCohort":false,"retrievedAt":["2026-07-22T15:51:53Z"],"status":"acquired"},"atlasGrid":{"column":4,"row":3},"comparability":{"caveat":"Historical normalized extract; no source-specific retention rule was verified. Until those conditions are aligned with another source, cross-state list-size, overlap, and restrictiveness comparisons are not established.","status":"not_established"},"postalCode":"IA","source":{"formats":["CSV"],"primary":{"format":"CSV","role":"data","url":"https://s3.amazonaws.com/tmp-gfx-public-data/banned-books20220819/banned_book_data_ia-list.csv"},"priority":"P1","scope":"Normalized historical state banned or restricted-publication records.","status":"ready","tier":"V2","vintage":"As of December 2021"},"state":"Iowa"},{"acquisition":{"artifactBytes":19215118,"artifactCount":1,"artifactFormats":["PDF"],"custodyCohort":"P2","integrity":"verified","p0ParserCohort":false,"retrievedAt":[],"status":"custody_verified_quarantined"},"atlasGrid":{"column":1,"row":2},"comparability":{"caveat":"Exact date boundaries, completeness, and retention policy require file-level validation. Until those conditions are aligned with another source, cross-state list-size, overlap, and restrictiveness comparisons are not established.","status":"not_established"},"postalCode":"ID","source":{"formats":["PDF"],"primary":{"format":"PDF","role":"data","url":"https://www.bookstoprisoners.net/_files/ugd/ea950d_24312dbbbf024b3488be3daa23c94654.pdf"},"priority":"P2","scope":"Mirrored Idaho prison publication-review lists from two recent vintages.","status":"validate_first","tier":"V1","vintage":"One 2021/2022 PDF and one 2023 PDF"},"state":"Idaho"},{"acquisition":{"artifactBytes":168021,"artifactCount":2,"artifactFormats":["PDF"],"custodyCohort":"P0","integrity":"verified","p0ParserCohort":true,"retrievedAt":["2026-07-22T14:08:09Z"],"status":"acquired"},"atlasGrid":{"column":5,"row":3},"comparability":{"caveat":"Coverage start and agency purge policy are not stated; treat the files as a dated response snapshot. Until those conditions are aligned with another source, cross-state list-size, overlap, and restrictiveness comparisons are not established.","status":"not_established"},"postalCode":"IL","source":{"formats":["PDF"],"primary":{"format":"PDF","role":"data","url":"https://cdn.muckrock.com/foia_files/2025/09/15/Banned_Books_9.11.25.pdf"},"priority":"P0","scope":"Two Illinois DOC categories released together: Banned Books and Disapproved Books.","status":"ready","tier":"V2","vintage":"Both files dated 2025-09-11 and supplied 2025-09-15"},"state":"Illinois"},{"acquisition":{"artifactBytes":18259,"artifactCount":1,"artifactFormats":["CSV"],"custodyCohort":"P1","integrity":"verified","p0ParserCohort":false,"retrievedAt":["2026-07-22T15:51:55Z"],"status":"acquired"},"atlasGrid":{"column":3,"row":5},"comparability":{"caveat":"Vintage descriptions differ between normalized and reporting sources; keep source snapshots distinct. Until those conditions are aligned with another source, cross-state list-size, overlap, and restrictiveness comparisons are not established.","status":"not_established"},"postalCode":"KS","source":{"formats":["CSV"],"primary":{"format":"CSV","role":"data","url":"https://s3.amazonaws.com/tmp-gfx-public-data/banned-books20220819/banned_book_data_ks-list.csv"},"priority":"P1","scope":"Normalized historical state banned or restricted-publication records.","status":"ready","tier":"V2","vintage":"As of 2022-02-01; PEN separately describes its 2023-obtained list as running through 2021"},"state":"Kansas"},{"acquisition":{"artifactBytes":246274,"artifactCount":1,"artifactFormats":["DOCX"],"custodyCohort":"P2","integrity":"verified","p0ParserCohort":false,"retrievedAt":["2026-07-22T18:59:19.762Z"],"status":"acquired"},"atlasGrid":{"column":4,"row":6},"comparability":{"caveat":"Coverage start, institutional reach, and retention policy require file-level validation. Until those conditions are aligned with another source, cross-state list-size, overlap, and restrictiveness comparisons are not established.","status":"not_established"},"postalCode":"LA","source":{"formats":["DOCX"],"primary":{"format":"DOCX","role":"data","url":"https://www.bookstoprisoners.net/_files/ugd/ea950d_85789755e05e488c8920f5ae8ffa2bef.docx?dn=Louisiana%20to%202023.docx"},"priority":"P2","scope":"Mirrored Louisiana prison publication list released through a public-record request.","status":"validate_first","tier":"V1","vintage":"Through February 2023"},"state":"Louisiana"},{"acquisition":{"artifactBytes":867771,"artifactCount":1,"artifactFormats":["PDF"],"custodyCohort":"P0","integrity":"verified","p0ParserCohort":true,"retrievedAt":["2026-07-22T14:08:09Z"],"status":"acquired"},"atlasGrid":{"column":7,"row":2},"comparability":{"caveat":"A static edition proves status only for its publication date; future replacement editions require snapshot diffing. Until those conditions are aligned with another source, cross-state list-size, overlap, and restrictiveness comparisons are not established.","status":"not_established"},"postalCode":"MI","source":{"formats":["PDF"],"primary":{"format":"PDF","role":"data","url":"https://www.michigan.gov/corrections/-/media/Project/Websites/corrections/Files/Public-Information/Restricted-Publication-List_1-12-2026.pdf?hash=B331889F6270846B473D00FD55D7ED09&rev=e9f9581906c4441885f14d4499280813"},"priority":"P0","scope":"Official statewide Restricted Publication List edition.","status":"ready","tier":"V3","vintage":"Edition dated 2026-01-12; official page updated 2026-01-20"},"state":"Michigan"},{"acquisition":{"artifactBytes":0,"artifactCount":0,"artifactFormats":[],"custodyCohort":null,"integrity":"not_applicable","p0ParserCohort":false,"retrievedAt":[],"status":"not_acquired"},"atlasGrid":{"column":4,"row":4},"comparability":{"caveat":"The Marshall Project changelog says Missouri was removed because it had been included in error; PEN independently reports no centralized list. Until those conditions are aligned with another source, cross-state list-size, overlap, and restrictiveness comparisons are not established.","status":"not_established"},"postalCode":"MO","source":{"formats":["none"],"primary":{"format":"HTML/notebook","role":"methodology","url":"https://observablehq.com/@themarshallproject/prison-banned-books"},"priority":"P3","scope":"Rejected research candidate; no verified centralized statewide publication dataset.","status":"excluded","tier":"V0","vintage":"No verified dataset"},"state":"Missouri"},{"acquisition":{"artifactBytes":22346,"artifactCount":1,"artifactFormats":["XLSX"],"custodyCohort":"P1","integrity":"verified","p0ParserCohort":false,"retrievedAt":["2026-07-22T15:51:56Z"],"status":"acquired"},"atlasGrid":{"column":2,"row":2},"comparability":{"caveat":"Exact 2023 boundary and agency retention policy require workbook inspection; retain both vintages as separate snapshots. Until those conditions are aligned with another source, cross-state list-size, overlap, and restrictiveness comparisons are not established.","status":"not_established"},"postalCode":"MT","source":{"formats":["XLSX","CSV"],"primary":{"format":"XLSX","role":"data","url":"https://www.bookstoprisoners.net/_files/ugd/ea950d_c65bca0fb5ab44b18b424e49cabe6774.xlsx?dn=Montana%20List.xlsx"},"priority":"P1","scope":"State publication records in a newer raw workbook plus an older normalized TMP extract.","status":"ready","tier":"V2","vintage":"Raw workbook described as 2012-2023; TMP extract as of 2022-04-21"},"state":"Montana"},{"acquisition":{"artifactBytes":33279,"artifactCount":1,"artifactFormats":["CSV"],"custodyCohort":"P1","integrity":"verified","p0ParserCohort":false,"retrievedAt":["2026-07-22T15:51:57Z"],"status":"acquired"},"atlasGrid":{"column":6,"row":5},"comparability":{"caveat":"PEN reports that North Carolina purges its list annually, so absence and list size are especially poor historical indicators. Until those conditions are aligned with another source, cross-state list-size, overlap, and restrictiveness comparisons are not established.","status":"not_established"},"postalCode":"NC","source":{"formats":["CSV"],"primary":{"format":"CSV","role":"data","url":"https://s3.amazonaws.com/tmp-gfx-public-data/banned-books20220819/banned_book_data_nc-list.csv"},"priority":"P1","scope":"Normalized historical state banned or restricted-publication records.","status":"ready","tier":"V2","vintage":"As of 2022-02-14"},"state":"North Carolina"},{"acquisition":{"artifactBytes":404992,"artifactCount":1,"artifactFormats":["XLS"],"custodyCohort":"P2","integrity":"verified","p0ParserCohort":false,"retrievedAt":["2026-07-22T18:59:20.362Z"],"status":"acquired"},"atlasGrid":{"column":3,"row":4},"comparability":{"caveat":"Historical endpoint, completeness, and agency retention policy require file-level validation. Until those conditions are aligned with another source, cross-state list-size, overlap, and restrictiveness comparisons are not established.","status":"not_established"},"postalCode":"NE","source":{"formats":["XLS"],"primary":{"format":"XLS","role":"data","url":"https://www.bookstoprisoners.net/_files/ugd/ea950d_a5c24e5439ed4dac97d708cc54c207f0.xls?dn=Nebraska%20TCSI%20.xls"},"priority":"P2","scope":"Mirrored Nebraska prison publication-review spreadsheet.","status":"validate_first","tier":"V1","vintage":"Entries described as 2011-2021"},"state":"Nebraska"},{"acquisition":{"artifactBytes":85232,"artifactCount":1,"artifactFormats":["PDF"],"custodyCohort":"P2","integrity":"verified","p0ParserCohort":false,"retrievedAt":["2026-07-22T18:59:20.913Z"],"status":"acquired"},"atlasGrid":{"column":10,"row":1},"comparability":{"caveat":"Narrow historical window only; completeness and retention policy are unverified. Until those conditions are aligned with another source, cross-state list-size, overlap, and restrictiveness comparisons are not established.","status":"not_established"},"postalCode":"NH","source":{"formats":["PDF"],"primary":{"format":"PDF","role":"data","url":"https://www.bookstoprisoners.net/_files/ugd/ea950d_47ef9598d9f54f8092789851ddf78359.pdf"},"priority":"P2","scope":"Historical mirrored New Hampshire prison publication list.","status":"validate_first","tier":"V1","vintage":"May/June 2019"},"state":"New Hampshire"},{"acquisition":{"artifactBytes":91040,"artifactCount":1,"artifactFormats":["PDF"],"custodyCohort":"P0","integrity":"verified","p0ParserCohort":true,"retrievedAt":["2026-07-22T14:08:09Z"],"status":"acquired"},"atlasGrid":{"column":9,"row":3},"comparability":{"caveat":"Static edition only; no agency purge rule was verified, and later replacement files may change the current list. Until those conditions are aligned with another source, cross-state list-size, overlap, and restrictiveness comparisons are not established.","status":"not_established"},"postalCode":"NJ","source":{"formats":["PDF"],"primary":{"format":"PDF","role":"data","url":"https://www.nj.gov/corrections/pdf/OffenderPublications/250616_NJDOC_UNAUTHORIZED_PUBLICATIONS.pdf"},"priority":"P0","scope":"Official statewide unauthorized-publications list.","status":"ready","tier":"V3","vintage":"PDF dated 2025-06-16"},"state":"New Jersey"},{"acquisition":{"artifactBytes":0,"artifactCount":0,"artifactFormats":[],"custodyCohort":null,"integrity":"not_applicable","p0ParserCohort":false,"retrievedAt":[],"status":"not_acquired"},"atlasGrid":{"column":8,"row":2},"comparability":{"caveat":"Not current and not directly downloadable; Books to Prisoners says the NYCLU ZIP is available only by email. Until those conditions are aligned with another source, cross-state list-size, overlap, and restrictiveness comparisons are not established.","status":"not_established"},"postalCode":"NY","source":{"formats":["none"],"primary":{"format":"Airtable index","role":"landing","url":"https://airtable.com/appIhuRjYftpulgc7/shrTAS7blzY92NZZQ"},"priority":"P3","scope":"Historical NYCLU-compiled state list identified by PEN, but no durable direct public file was found.","status":"blocked","tier":"V0","vintage":"Reported through 2019; PEN cites 5,356 titles as of 2019-02-27"},"state":"New York"},{"acquisition":{"artifactBytes":158318,"artifactCount":1,"artifactFormats":["PDF"],"custodyCohort":"P2","integrity":"verified","p0ParserCohort":false,"retrievedAt":["2026-07-22T18:59:21.505Z"],"status":"acquired"},"atlasGrid":{"column":7,"row":3},"comparability":{"caveat":"Historical snapshot only; coverage start, completeness, and retention policy are unverified. Until those conditions are aligned with another source, cross-state list-size, overlap, and restrictiveness comparisons are not established.","status":"not_established"},"postalCode":"OH","source":{"formats":["PDF"],"primary":{"format":"PDF","role":"data","url":"https://www.bookstoprisoners.net/_files/ugd/ea950d_e12084fcc10a4dea820e8da43e767936.pdf"},"priority":"P2","scope":"Historical mirrored Ohio prison publication list.","status":"validate_first","tier":"V1","vintage":"January 2022"},"state":"Ohio"},{"acquisition":{"artifactBytes":472576,"artifactCount":1,"artifactFormats":["XLS"],"custodyCohort":"P1","integrity":"verified","p0ParserCohort":false,"retrievedAt":["2026-07-22T15:51:59Z"],"status":"acquired"},"atlasGrid":{"column":0,"row":3},"comparability":{"caveat":"PEN reports a three-year purge cycle, so the list is a rolling window rather than a complete historical record. Until those conditions are aligned with another source, cross-state list-size, overlap, and restrictiveness comparisons are not established.","status":"not_established"},"postalCode":"OR","source":{"formats":["XLS","CSV"],"primary":{"format":"XLS","role":"data","url":"https://www.bookstoprisoners.net/_files/ugd/ea950d_7d07959ba7de4e0e978d95f154aa688b.xls?dn=Oregon%20Rejected%202023.xls"},"priority":"P1","scope":"Rejected-publication records in a newer raw spreadsheet plus an older normalized TMP extract.","status":"ready","tier":"V2","vintage":"Raw rejected-publications spreadsheet labeled 2023; TMP extract as of 2022-02-01"},"state":"Oregon"},{"acquisition":{"artifactBytes":0,"artifactCount":0,"artifactFormats":[],"custodyCohort":null,"integrity":"not_applicable","p0ParserCohort":false,"retrievedAt":[],"status":"not_acquired"},"atlasGrid":{"column":8,"row":3},"comparability":{"caveat":"PEN reports annual purging; the official page also limits scope to final determinations, sharply constraining historical and cross-state comparisons. Until those conditions are aligned with another source, cross-state list-size, overlap, and restrictiveness comparisons are not established.","status":"not_established"},"postalCode":"PA","source":{"formats":["XLSX"],"primary":{"availability":"HTTP 404 on 2026-07-22","format":"XLSX","role":"data","url":"https://www.pa.gov/content/dam/copapwp-pagov/en/cor/documents/resources/for-family-and-friends/doc-publication-denial-listing.xlsx"},"priority":"P3","scope":"Official final denied-publication determinations after the appeal process; current download is unavailable.","status":"blocked","tier":"V0","vintage":"Official page checked 2026-07-22; linked XLSX returned 404"},"state":"Pennsylvania"},{"acquisition":{"artifactBytes":33127,"artifactCount":1,"artifactFormats":["XLSX"],"custodyCohort":"P1","integrity":"verified","p0ParserCohort":false,"retrievedAt":["2026-07-22T15:52:00Z"],"status":"acquired"},"atlasGrid":{"column":11,"row":3},"comparability":{"caveat":"Exact date boundaries and agency retention policy require workbook inspection; retain both vintages as separate snapshots. Until those conditions are aligned with another source, cross-state list-size, overlap, and restrictiveness comparisons are not established.","status":"not_established"},"postalCode":"RI","source":{"formats":["XLSX","CSV"],"primary":{"format":"XLSX","role":"data","url":"https://www.bookstoprisoners.net/_files/ugd/ea950d_c7145bd90cd34b00843572f886113b03.xlsx?dn=Rhode%20Island.xlsx"},"priority":"P1","scope":"State publication records in a newer raw workbook plus an older normalized TMP extract.","status":"ready","tier":"V2","vintage":"Raw workbook described as 2018-2023; TMP extract as of November 2022"},"state":"Rhode Island"},{"acquisition":{"artifactBytes":104300,"artifactCount":1,"artifactFormats":["CSV"],"custodyCohort":"P1","integrity":"verified","p0ParserCohort":false,"retrievedAt":["2026-07-22T15:52:06Z"],"status":"acquired"},"atlasGrid":{"column":7,"row":5},"comparability":{"caveat":"Historical normalized extract; no source-specific retention rule was verified. Until those conditions are aligned with another source, cross-state list-size, overlap, and restrictiveness comparisons are not established.","status":"not_established"},"postalCode":"SC","source":{"formats":["CSV"],"primary":{"format":"CSV","role":"data","url":"https://s3.amazonaws.com/tmp-gfx-public-data/banned-books20220819/banned_book_data_sc-list.csv"},"priority":"P1","scope":"Normalized historical state banned or restricted-publication records.","status":"ready","tier":"V2","vintage":"As of 2022-02-19"},"state":"South Carolina"},{"acquisition":{"artifactBytes":4477190,"artifactCount":1,"artifactFormats":["XML"],"custodyCohort":"P0","integrity":"verified","p0ParserCohort":true,"retrievedAt":["2026-07-22T14:08:09Z"],"status":"acquired"},"atlasGrid":{"column":3,"row":7},"comparability":{"caveat":"A dated FOIA export is not live; no source-specific purge rule was verified. Until those conditions are aligned with another source, cross-state list-size, overlap, and restrictiveness comparisons are not established.","status":"not_established"},"postalCode":"TX","source":{"formats":["XML"],"primary":{"format":"XML","role":"data","url":"https://cdn.muckrock.com/foia_files/2025/09/12/DENIED_BOOKS_20250702.xml"},"priority":"P0","scope":"TDCJ denied-books export released through a 2025 public-record request.","status":"ready","tier":"V2","vintage":"Export as of 2025-07-02, supplied 2025-09-12"},"state":"Texas"},{"acquisition":{"artifactBytes":796638,"artifactCount":1,"artifactFormats":["XLSX"],"custodyCohort":"P1","integrity":"verified","p0ParserCohort":false,"retrievedAt":["2026-07-22T15:52:09Z"],"status":"acquired"},"atlasGrid":{"column":7,"row":4},"comparability":{"caveat":"Exact start date, completeness, and agency retention policy require workbook inspection. Until those conditions are aligned with another source, cross-state list-size, overlap, and restrictiveness comparisons are not established.","status":"not_established"},"postalCode":"VA","source":{"formats":["XLSX","CSV"],"primary":{"format":"XLSX","role":"data","url":"https://www.bookstoprisoners.net/_files/ugd/ea950d_e5b62f01b9e34f43bc1b2788e6ee9126.xlsx?dn=Virginia%20to%202022.xlsx"},"priority":"P1","scope":"State publication records in a raw workbook, cross-checked against a normalized TMP extract.","status":"ready","tier":"V2","vintage":"Raw workbook through December 2022; TMP extract as of November 2022"},"state":"Virginia"},{"acquisition":{"artifactBytes":9018935,"artifactCount":1,"artifactFormats":["PDF"],"custodyCohort":"P0","integrity":"verified","p0ParserCohort":true,"retrievedAt":["2026-07-22T14:08:09Z"],"status":"acquired"},"atlasGrid":{"column":0,"row":2},"comparability":{"caveat":"Official page calls it comprehensive for committee-reviewed denials, but no purge rule was verified; appeal reversals materially affect totals. Until those conditions are aligned with another source, cross-state list-size, overlap, and restrictiveness comparisons are not established.","status":"not_established"},"postalCode":"WA","source":{"formats":["PDF"],"primary":{"format":"PDF","role":"data","url":"https://doc.wa.gov/sites/default/files/2026-02/400-RE003.pdf"},"priority":"P0","scope":"Official Publication Review Log containing review, committee, and appeal outcomes.","status":"ready","tier":"V3","vintage":"Publication Review Log, February 2026"},"state":"Washington"},{"acquisition":{"artifactBytes":295218,"artifactCount":2,"artifactFormats":["CSV"],"custodyCohort":"P1","integrity":"verified","p0ParserCohort":false,"retrievedAt":["2026-07-22T15:52:09Z"],"status":"acquired"},"atlasGrid":{"column":5,"row":2},"comparability":{"caveat":"Two extracts may overlap or represent different scopes; do not concatenate without source-aware deduplication. Until those conditions are aligned with another source, cross-state list-size, overlap, and restrictiveness comparisons are not established.","status":"not_established"},"postalCode":"WI","source":{"formats":["CSV"],"primary":{"format":"CSV","role":"data","url":"https://s3.amazonaws.com/tmp-gfx-public-data/banned-books20220819/banned_book_data_wi-list-1.csv"},"priority":"P1","scope":"Two normalized historical state publication-list extracts.","status":"ready","tier":"V2","vintage":"Two TMP snapshots: 2022-02-21 and 2022-07-31"},"state":"Wisconsin"},{"acquisition":{"artifactBytes":22592,"artifactCount":1,"artifactFormats":["DOCX"],"custodyCohort":"P2","integrity":"verified","p0ParserCohort":false,"retrievedAt":["2026-07-22T18:59:22.025Z"],"status":"acquired"},"atlasGrid":{"column":2,"row":3},"comparability":{"caveat":"Coverage start, completeness, institutional reach, and retention policy require file-level validation. Until those conditions are aligned with another source, cross-state list-size, overlap, and restrictiveness comparisons are not established.","status":"not_established"},"postalCode":"WY","source":{"formats":["DOCX"],"primary":{"format":"DOCX","role":"data","url":"https://www.bookstoprisoners.net/_files/ugd/ea950d_78702e7fc3ea4be6b4a0e73e2cad0561.docx?dn=Wyoming%20publications-%202022.docx"},"priority":"P2","scope":"Mirrored Wyoming prison publication list released through a public-record request.","status":"validate_first","tier":"V1","vintage":"Through 2022-10-26"},"state":"Wyoming"}],"summary":{"acquisitionCohorts":{"P0":{"artifactBytes":18438510,"artifactCount":10,"p0ParserCohort":true,"purpose":"locked_parser_input","stateCodes":["CA","FL","GA","IL","MI","NJ","TX","WA"],"statesWithArtifacts":8},"P1":{"artifactBytes":2524987,"artifactCount":13,"p0ParserCohort":false,"purpose":"custody_only","stateCodes":["AZ","CO","CT","IA","KS","MT","NC","OR","RI","SC","VA","WI"],"statesWithArtifacts":12},"P2":{"acceptedArtifactBytes":917408,"acceptedArtifactCount":5,"artifactBytes":20132526,"artifactCount":6,"p0ParserCohort":false,"purpose":"custody_only","refusedArtifactCount":1,"stateCodes":["ID","LA","NE","NH","OH","WY"],"statesWithArtifacts":6}},"acquisitionStatusCounts":{"acquired":25,"custody_verified_quarantined":1,"failed":0,"not_acquired":3,"partial":0},"artifactIntegrity":"verified","priorityCounts":{"P0":8,"P1":12,"P2":6,"P3":3},"sourceStatusCounts":{"blocked":2,"excluded":1,"ready":20,"validate_first":6},"stateCount":29,"statesWithArtifacts":26,"statesWithoutArtifacts":3,"tierCounts":{"V0":3,"V1":6,"V2":15,"V3":5},"totalArtifactBytes":41096023,"totalArtifactCount":29}}